French and U.K. Fishing Boats Clash in ‘Scallop War’
LONDON — It’s been called the “scallop war” — a simmering rivalry that spilled out into the open again this week when French and British vessels clashed in the English Channel, French fishermen tossed what appeared to be smoke bombs at their rivals, and the British called on the Royal Navy for protection.
Video footage on French state television and on social media showed about 35 small French fishing boats menacing five larger British vessels early Tuesday morning in a stretch of international waters that separates Britain from the rest of Europe, just off the northwest coast of France.
At least one French boat slammed into the side of a Scottish vessel.
A French official said no one had been injured in the clash, but called the encounter “extremely dangerous.”
The French argue that British fishing vessels have an unfair advantage. The French government does not allow fishing for scallops to begin until October, in order to preserve the stock.
But the British have no such restrictions. Large boats from as far as Scotland visit these waters every year in hopes of making a good catch, within fishing quotas.
Dimitry Rogoff, head of the regional fisheries committee in Normandy, France, told The Guardian newspaper, “For the Brits, it’s an open bar — they fish when they want, where they want, and as much as they want.”
“We don’t want to stop them from fishing,” he added, “but they could at least wait until Oct. 1 so that we can share.” He was not immediately available for comment on Wednesday.
The French vessels set out from the Normandy ports of Port-en-Bessin, Courseulles, Ouistreham, Trouville, Honfleur and Le Havre to chase British boats away from the Baie de la Seine, where the seabed is rich in scallops.
One video showed two smaller French boats navigating close to a larger Scottish vessel, with one slamming into its side. (A Scottish ship and its owner were convicted last November of catching scallops smaller than the permitted minimum size, and ordered to pay a total of 29,000 pounds, around $37,300.)
Video posted by the master of the French boat showed smoke or steam rising from the larger vessel. The French state television network France 3 said it appeared smoke bombs had been thrown.
“There were some fairly strong clashes,” Lt. Ingrid Parrot, the spokeswoman for the French regional maritime authority, said by phone on Wednesday.
“This kind of event is extremely dangerous at sea,” she said, adding that the authorities would remain vigilant for signs of flare-ups.
Britain’s National Federation of Fishermen’s Organizations said it had asked the Royal Navy for protection, since the vessels were operating in the waters legally.
Michael Gove, the British environment secretary, said in an emailed statement on Wednesday afternoon: “My heart goes out to the British fishermen who were caught up in the terrible scenes that we saw happen earlier this week. They were fishing entirely legally; they had every right to be in those waters.”
The statement said that the British government was “in contact with industry and the French administration to encourage meaningful dialogue and prevent further incidents from occurring.”
The tensions between fishing vessels in the Baie de la Seine has existed for more than a decade. The French and British sides previously struck agreements about the scallops in previous years to avoid the very clashes that occurred at dawn on Tuesday.
The last time such a clash occurred, in 2012, the French Navy was called to intervene after 40 French boats surrounded five British vessels in the same area.
European Union regulations have for decades given fishing vessels from other member states access to Britain’s fishing stock.
Mr. Rogoff said that things might change next year if Britain exited the European Union without a deal.
After March 29, 2019, he said of the British vessels, “they would be treated as a third party and would no longer have access to these areas.”
Fishing waters rights was an issue in the debate before the country voted to leave the European Union, a process known as Brexit. British organizations like Fishing for Leave campaigned to take back control of British waters. On Wednesday, that group condemned the clashes.
In the “soft Brexit” scenario currently being pursued by the government of Prime Minister Theresa May, Britain would not withdraw immediately from the European Common Fisheries Policy.
Fishing accounts for less than half a percent of Britain’s G.D.P., but English fishing boats currently depend on fishing in European Union waters and on exporting to the Continent.
Follow Palko Karasz on Twitter: @karaszpalko.